crit notes part 2

i thought that this page looked a lot more pro than the 1st one but at the crit people hated it. its apparently very unproffesional to have things like my buttons being on the right instead of the left, if the page is wide than people may have to scroll to get to the buttons if they're on the right so they may not even notice them.
people also said the other idea catches the eye better because its bolder and brighter.